Thursday, September 18, 2014

Update on Classes, SBG and CEJ

Classes are going better now that we've gotten through the biochemistry and they all breathe a collective sigh of relief - it feels like biology now :)

AP is working into Unit 2 - Evolution and Honors Biology is still in Unit 1 - but the topic is cells.

The SBG has gone well (although I'm behind right now :P - must do tonight and tomorrow on my last day of Fall Break) and the parents at curriculum night liked it as it is very specific for the feedback. Once I do this next round of feedback, I will put that into our "formal" grade system. I'm still working my way through Active Grade to determine how best to align the 4 point scale with the "standard" scale. As I told parents that night, the first one will be around 10 points in value - because it's so new, I don't want grades to tank. Some of the standards have only been assessed once, so that's another issue - we just haven't done enough yet!

The CEJ (Claim/Evidence/Justification) is just awesome. LOVING using this in class. It took a bit to get them used to it. I did a modified version of the Beak of the Finch activities from HHMI Biointeractive - it worked GREAT! Other than the wifi not working in my classroom (what a shock) they did a great job. It's still new - so many of them are still weak on the justification section. What was great is during presentations, without prompting, each class got into a discussion of which data was best to use to make the point. Some argued for two data sets, others tried to refute it. It was a good exercise in evaluation of data to use as evidence - a LOT of higher level thinking going on. Here is a sample board from AP biology:




Honors biology actually did an ADI (Argument-Drive Inquiry) lab from the NSTA book. They did it on cells. They had 4 known slides to observe and make notes on - 2 animal/2 plant. Then, they had an unknown slide. Based on their observations, they had to classify the unknown and the instructions were pretty explicit - plant or animal? Here is a sample whiteboard (the best one as they actually made a data table of sorts to categorize their observations) for that:
Now, what they didn't know, and was all kinds of fun for me, was that the unknown slide was actually a Euglena - neither plant nor animal. So, I showed them un-stained pictures of Euglena on the SmartBoard, as well as one that was labeled with the chloroplasts and eyespot. We then had a quick discussion on what that could mean. Next, I showed them a quick YouTube video of a Euglena moving. Then, they had 15 minutes to revise their arguments and take a picture of their boards to do a final summary. Most were still trying to "fit" it into one of the two categories, then one group figured out there are more types of cells and started discussing other cell types. That conversation spread like wildfire and some even pulled their books out to look up other cell types since they couldn't remember the information from 7th grade life science. For one or two groups, I did have to give them the page number to reference in their books since they were just stumped. These are groups that I already know are going to have issues in the course as they are struggling already - and this type of activity should be review for many of them.




So, success with these first two - "official" - arguments. I will definitely continue to do these! There is much class discussion and learning that is going on as I move around and listen to conversations. The presentations are a necessity to get them speaking about these topics and asking/answering questions of each other. This is simply another modification of whiteboarding that I have used in my classroom for years.

On a final note, I am LOVING the collaboration with one of the other honors teachers and the new teacher. We are actually sharing assessments and doing common summative assessments (aka tests). It is so nice to finally have someone to bounce ideas off of!!! As we were talking about the cells ADI, we actually had a quick 5 minutes conversation on how to do one for mitosis when we get to that point! Again, refreshing and really wonderful to have other teachers to collaborate with :)