Thursday, September 18, 2014

Update on Classes, SBG and CEJ

Classes are going better now that we've gotten through the biochemistry and they all breathe a collective sigh of relief - it feels like biology now :)

AP is working into Unit 2 - Evolution and Honors Biology is still in Unit 1 - but the topic is cells.

The SBG has gone well (although I'm behind right now :P - must do tonight and tomorrow on my last day of Fall Break) and the parents at curriculum night liked it as it is very specific for the feedback. Once I do this next round of feedback, I will put that into our "formal" grade system. I'm still working my way through Active Grade to determine how best to align the 4 point scale with the "standard" scale. As I told parents that night, the first one will be around 10 points in value - because it's so new, I don't want grades to tank. Some of the standards have only been assessed once, so that's another issue - we just haven't done enough yet!

The CEJ (Claim/Evidence/Justification) is just awesome. LOVING using this in class. It took a bit to get them used to it. I did a modified version of the Beak of the Finch activities from HHMI Biointeractive - it worked GREAT! Other than the wifi not working in my classroom (what a shock) they did a great job. It's still new - so many of them are still weak on the justification section. What was great is during presentations, without prompting, each class got into a discussion of which data was best to use to make the point. Some argued for two data sets, others tried to refute it. It was a good exercise in evaluation of data to use as evidence - a LOT of higher level thinking going on. Here is a sample board from AP biology:




Honors biology actually did an ADI (Argument-Drive Inquiry) lab from the NSTA book. They did it on cells. They had 4 known slides to observe and make notes on - 2 animal/2 plant. Then, they had an unknown slide. Based on their observations, they had to classify the unknown and the instructions were pretty explicit - plant or animal? Here is a sample whiteboard (the best one as they actually made a data table of sorts to categorize their observations) for that:
Now, what they didn't know, and was all kinds of fun for me, was that the unknown slide was actually a Euglena - neither plant nor animal. So, I showed them un-stained pictures of Euglena on the SmartBoard, as well as one that was labeled with the chloroplasts and eyespot. We then had a quick discussion on what that could mean. Next, I showed them a quick YouTube video of a Euglena moving. Then, they had 15 minutes to revise their arguments and take a picture of their boards to do a final summary. Most were still trying to "fit" it into one of the two categories, then one group figured out there are more types of cells and started discussing other cell types. That conversation spread like wildfire and some even pulled their books out to look up other cell types since they couldn't remember the information from 7th grade life science. For one or two groups, I did have to give them the page number to reference in their books since they were just stumped. These are groups that I already know are going to have issues in the course as they are struggling already - and this type of activity should be review for many of them.




So, success with these first two - "official" - arguments. I will definitely continue to do these! There is much class discussion and learning that is going on as I move around and listen to conversations. The presentations are a necessity to get them speaking about these topics and asking/answering questions of each other. This is simply another modification of whiteboarding that I have used in my classroom for years.

On a final note, I am LOVING the collaboration with one of the other honors teachers and the new teacher. We are actually sharing assessments and doing common summative assessments (aka tests). It is so nice to finally have someone to bounce ideas off of!!! As we were talking about the cells ADI, we actually had a quick 5 minutes conversation on how to do one for mitosis when we get to that point! Again, refreshing and really wonderful to have other teachers to collaborate with :)

Wednesday, August 20, 2014

Scaffolding on their first lab

So AP had their first long lab this week. The termite lab was long, but didn't link to any particular concepts - but rather it was to get them involved and thinking on a higher level right off the bat. This was their first "official" AP style lab - buffers.

So, I scaffolded quite a bit with this one. We had a good introduction to the lab on Friday of last week. They did the pre-lab questions over the weekend and I verified those on Monday before they began. We did the "tool talk" on Friday to show the equipment and answer questions about procedure. It's not a very intricate lab in terms of procedure. I did have them use the LabQuests, just to get used to using them in lab since they will frequently. They didn't use them for graphing or save data - it was really just using the probe and the interface. They ran the baselines on Monday, and then ran unknown buffer solutions on Tuesday. Note to self: get simulated ocean water next year! I just want to see if there is, actually, a buffer system in the simulated sea water.

So today is the third day and we did some scaffolding to get them through this:
  • I went back to the overall question for the lab. I didn't do this last year - the question or a relationship for them. I think this was a critical piece that was missing to help them make connections.
  • I specifically highlighted the learning objectives for them. I also pointed out WHY these were important and how they would be assessed. 
  • I also reviewed the science practices that will be used for the Standards-Based Grading. I really wanted to them to understand the difference between the objectives - so I did a quick Q&A session with them.
  • We did group data and then I asked them what we should do to all the data going up on the Smart Board - answer: average! And then: Why? They don't have time to do multiple trials, so this is the compromise. 
  • The final step was having them discuss in lab groups what data would be best to use to graph to answer the scientific question - still going back to that for emphasis.
I have also changed the Conclusions to make it all about the Claim, Evidence, Justification. I like my new poster on the wall that shows / describes how the Claim relates to the Evidence that relates to the Justification. The Evidence is really the "glue" in the middle that allows them to justify the claim - and that is now a huge part of the AP curriculum.

I am modeling some of this from the Argumentation-Driven Inquiry. I am having to modify it, simply because I don't have the time to do it the way they describe. I understand the benefits, and if I had an entire year and not just 10 months, I probably could do some of it. But, I think this is working so far. I'll have another update once I can actually assess what they are doing. 

Thursday, August 14, 2014

Some thoughts about newer teachers - and remembering where I was so very long ago...

I feel like I should begin this as in Star Wars "A long time ago, in a school far, far away..." there was a new teacher who had really great ideas and thought she could do it all on her own - wrong-o!

We have some new teachers in our school and department, and it amuses me that things are said the same way by new teachers as they were by me almost 20 years ago. I think I've reached that stage - you know, the one where you finally know what you don't know and can begin to really make strides in getting better and improving as a teacher. Just in the last several years, I feel as though I've grown by leaps and bounds because I finally have figured out what I don't know and, more importantly, what I need to do in order to improve.

So here are the stages, for anyone reading this who doesn't know them, and were taught to me by my very wise and valued mentor.
  • You don't know what you know - stage 1
  • You don't know what you don't know - stage 2
  • You know what you know - stage 3
  • You know what you don't know - stage 4
What is amusing to me is the type of things I'm seeing - new teachers trying to re-invent the wheel and "working in a vacuum." I think I did this at my very first school for 6 months. When I moved schools, I found a mentor straightaway. It didn't take me long to figure out that I needed someone to help me with things.

What I heard specifically was a newer teacher talking with someone in the same subject area. The newbie said "Well, we could work together, but I really prefer to develop things so I can make them my own" - what startled me is that this teacher didn't realize that you can easily modify something to make it yours - and bouncing ideas off of someone else can sometimes lead you to an area that you wouldn't have thought of on your own.

Currently, I'm trying to work with the new teacher and I ask her opinion. Why? Because I want her involved and I also want to her to know that her contributions do matter. But more importantly, by including her, she is also learning - whether she knows it or not. It's refreshing to finally be able to collaborate as the mentor, rather then the mentee.  Wow, I'm getting old. 

Saturday, August 9, 2014

First week done - Termite Lab report using Argumentation Model

Our first week is officially done. Wow - it went by Q.U.I.C.K! I MUST be getting old!

At any rate, I did a modified version of the termite argumentation model with my students. Most of the modification was taking the paper down to a reasonable level (i.e. one page front & 1/2 of the back), giving them some room to write in the margins, and adding the Science Practices for their first SBG assessment. The short version of what I did:
  • Day 1: Went over class basics for 5-10 minutes. Introduced the termites and allowed them to observe their behavior on the paper - they drew a figure 8 in red ballpoint pen ink. Went over "how to care for your termite" in 2 min or less - they are very delicate little beasties! Once they were done, we came back together as a group and I passed out the Termite Argument with the 3 different claims. I had them use the RATE strategy to begin working on their experimental design. I posted the experimental design on my SMART Board so if they got to that point, they could begin making some notes.
  • Day 2: Passed out the giant chart paper - gave them about 20-25 min to talk/discuss and then put their design on paper. They taped them to the walls outside (I have almost 0 space in my room to do these activities due to the lab stations - NOT complaining about that...) and I took a "clean" picture of each paper prior to them doing the Gallery Walk. I did my walk a little differently - I give them 4 post-it notes. They make two positive comments & two suggestions. I scaffolded some and gave them examples of good and poor commentary (still sorting through those). They do put first name & last initial on the post-its - this is for translation purposes with handwriting and for me to review them later and make suggestions. While they were doing that, I used the photo editor on my tablet to write in my own comments on the pictures of their posters - HUGE TIME SAVER!!! Later that night, I uploaded the annotated photo and comments + SBG score into Active Grade. I'm sure I'll become more proficient at doing that - the first time took a bit :P
  • Day 3: Got them set up in Active Grade - had them sort their post-its on their charts to + piles and suggestions pile so they could begin to revise. Gave them about 20-25 min to revise, then run their design after that time period until end of class. Introduced the claim/evidence/justification (response) model once all the termites were back in their temporary home. HW that night - decide which claim to support and outline evidence and justification for it.
  • Day 4: Ran the argumentation session using whiteboards. I do my presentations differently than the round robin format. That requires one student to "stay back" and answer questions, so they do not get to participate in the rest of the discussion. I'll explain my method in another post. After that, we discussed how to convert their whiteboard argument into a formal summary. We definitely reviewed the differences in scientific writing vs. English class writing - to put it bluntly, they were relieved. HW - write the summary.

So, I've started assessing the labs and the summaries - they are actually getting several different "grades" (I need to stop using that word!) for this lab. The first was an SBG assessment - SP4.2 from CB - Plan & Implement Data Collection Strategies - that was the comments on their posters and further comments in Active Grade on a 0-4 scale. This was also a group type of grade - so nothing individual just yet. Made it easy to copy/paste the comments for each group - I got to know who was in what group better, and the scoring was a little faster than what I did earlier today. I did do a "formal" lab grade for their lab revisions and data collection they actually conducted. Some were still weak and did not take the comments I made into consideration. Example: one group had no controls listed at all and several group did not indicate the different levels of their independent variables. I don't *think* they will be asked to completely redesign a lab as an FRQ as in years past on the AP exam, however, they DO need to recognize elements of good and poor lab design (oooohhhh..... I feel a good, general FRQ coming on from this lab!). Finally, I'm going through the summaries today and scoring/assessing those on the SBG 0-4 scale. I've only done one class so far, but I only had a couple of 1.5 scores where they just did not provide parts of the argument that were essential. Most grades were in the 2-2.5 range, and a couple that I couldn't quite give a 3 yet, but still had outstanding elements that I did a 2.75.

I've only done one class, but it's promising. I did enjoy being able to TYPE the comments into Active Grade! I type so much faster than I write AND they can READ the comments - most cannot read my handwriting. I still made notes in their lab notebooks re: their lab design - but the specificity of Active Grade is just fantastic. LOVE IT!

Once I figure out how to get some pictures up onto the blog from my tablet, I'll post.

All in all - a really good start to AP this week. Have not gotten to the honors SBG yet - but that will happen this weekend. So there might be another post....

Thursday, July 17, 2014

Analysis of Last Year and Implications for the new year

Teaching AP Bio is its own little monster. It has become increasingly challenging with the new curriculum framework and the change in the test. It is more focused on analysis and critical thinking vs. regurgitation (to which I am NOT opposed). However, it is also more heavily weighted for student writing - moving from 4 long free response questions and morphing into 2 long responses, and 6 short responses - worth varying amounts of points and addressing different concepts and science practices. The weighting has also changed. Instead of 60/40 split for the multiple choice/free response, it is now 50/50 - including math calculations (aka "grid-in" questions) on the multiple choice. So, the writing portion of the test has become more critical.

For the past two years of the new framework, I've had students who I strongly felt should have been at the 5 level on the exam - and yet made 4's. To me, it's more of a reflection on myself and my teaching. Although I shouldn't look at it that way, it does make me feel as though I have failed those students. So, I analyzed what was happening throughout the year and came up with three specific areas that I want to adjust/change in order to have my students not only improve on the AP exam, but also to go further in-depth in biology and perhaps encourage more students to pursue a career in the sciences after taking the course.

Here are the weaknesses I identified:
  • Writing - their Free Response questions just did NOT progress as they have in previous years
  • Lab Skills and Connections - they just weren't making connections between the labs. I saw the same errors being made on just about every lab. Graphing skills in particular were not good. They also could not connect what was being done in the lab to the overall concepts being discussed in class. 
  • Quantitative Skills - just like the lab skills and connections, they just couldn't connect with "what does the data mean" and "what do I need to do to manipulate the data so it can be analyzed" - they had to be told repeatedly to convert to percentages for comparisons. 
So, these are the things that caused me concern - it was a constant struggle all the way through the end of the year. So, here are my proposed ideas to address these issues (and I should note that this is really a reflection of the past 2 years, not just one):
  • Formative Assessment - especially for writing. I'm going to follow the SE2R model as much as possible that was done by Mark Barnes (so glad I stumbled upon this!)  Basically, it guides teachers in how to apply FA to student work: Summarize, Explain, Redirect and Resubmit. Yes, this will take more time initially, but I think as students improve (which is the ultimate goal) that time will be shorter. 
  • Bellringers - this is something that (for whatever reason) I moved away from over the years. I cannot afford the time to do them everyday, but at least twice per week. I'm calling them BILL Activities - BILL = Biology Interactive Learning Log - used by Lee Ferguson and I'm adapting it NOW. There are other ways they will use the BILL besides bellringers as well. Also, I have fallen in LOVE with Socrative 2.0! My students can put that on their devices and we can use it for bellringers and/or exit tickets. Another source of FA as well as practice.
  • Standards-Based Grading - I know many AP bio teachers (and others) have gone to full-on SBG for everything. I simply am not there yet. So, as one person posted on the Forum "Assess using SBG with what you deem is important." I like that. I can tailor this to fit specific needs. So, it will be used to specifically address 2-3 Science Practices or Argumentation Standards per lab. This is more manageable. I can also use this during Argumentation Sessions (which I moving to that more heavily this year). I have set up ActiveGrade and loaded in my standards - I'm now to the point of loading in the assessments and linking them to the standards. Once every 3 weeks, I'll convert the SBG into an actual "grade" for our normal grading system. The neat thing about ActiveGrade is I can upload annotated pictures or audio feedback, as well as leave typed comments. Since I type faster than I write, and it also has parent access, students and parents can see, very specifically, what they need to work on for improvement. 
My next goals:
  • Create a matrix that aligns my labs with the Science Practices to be assessed for SBG - this is going to take some time as I'm in the process of revamping my labs for this very purpose. Also making them more inquiry-based (less structured and more guided inquiry).
  • Create the bellringers - I did brainstorm a list of ideas that I can do that are not topic specific - so I've already got the unit 1 bellringers for both AP and my honors biology classes.
  • Formative Assessment Probes - I looked at the FAP books by Keeley through NSTA - and they aren't as specific to bio and the AP level as I would like - meaning I'd still have to fiddle with them to make them work. So, I decided to just create my own. The first one that I did for honors actually didn't take terribly long, and I found a PDF online that had the 5 examples of FAPs to use for development.
  • Socrative - I'm just getting this set up. I have unit 1 done for AP and honors - moving on to the next....
  •  SBG info for parents and students - I have a basic pamphlet put together that addresses this, but I need something more specific to hand out at the freshmen orientation and also to send home. It is completely new for this school and community, so parents and students need to understand how much this is going to HELP them improve and be successful. 
I should also mention - my students aren't really struggling with the content of the course as much as in the past.This is also due to the new framework removing a LOT of information and really focusing in on the Big Ideas of Biology (thank goodness for UbD!!! - yes, revising my plans as well...). So, what I'm doing to get the content across is not the problem, the usage of the content and what I've mentioned above ARE part of the problem.

I have 2 weeks and 3 days until students arrive. Let's see how much I can get done by then...