Saturday, August 9, 2014

First week done - Termite Lab report using Argumentation Model

Our first week is officially done. Wow - it went by Q.U.I.C.K! I MUST be getting old!

At any rate, I did a modified version of the termite argumentation model with my students. Most of the modification was taking the paper down to a reasonable level (i.e. one page front & 1/2 of the back), giving them some room to write in the margins, and adding the Science Practices for their first SBG assessment. The short version of what I did:
  • Day 1: Went over class basics for 5-10 minutes. Introduced the termites and allowed them to observe their behavior on the paper - they drew a figure 8 in red ballpoint pen ink. Went over "how to care for your termite" in 2 min or less - they are very delicate little beasties! Once they were done, we came back together as a group and I passed out the Termite Argument with the 3 different claims. I had them use the RATE strategy to begin working on their experimental design. I posted the experimental design on my SMART Board so if they got to that point, they could begin making some notes.
  • Day 2: Passed out the giant chart paper - gave them about 20-25 min to talk/discuss and then put their design on paper. They taped them to the walls outside (I have almost 0 space in my room to do these activities due to the lab stations - NOT complaining about that...) and I took a "clean" picture of each paper prior to them doing the Gallery Walk. I did my walk a little differently - I give them 4 post-it notes. They make two positive comments & two suggestions. I scaffolded some and gave them examples of good and poor commentary (still sorting through those). They do put first name & last initial on the post-its - this is for translation purposes with handwriting and for me to review them later and make suggestions. While they were doing that, I used the photo editor on my tablet to write in my own comments on the pictures of their posters - HUGE TIME SAVER!!! Later that night, I uploaded the annotated photo and comments + SBG score into Active Grade. I'm sure I'll become more proficient at doing that - the first time took a bit :P
  • Day 3: Got them set up in Active Grade - had them sort their post-its on their charts to + piles and suggestions pile so they could begin to revise. Gave them about 20-25 min to revise, then run their design after that time period until end of class. Introduced the claim/evidence/justification (response) model once all the termites were back in their temporary home. HW that night - decide which claim to support and outline evidence and justification for it.
  • Day 4: Ran the argumentation session using whiteboards. I do my presentations differently than the round robin format. That requires one student to "stay back" and answer questions, so they do not get to participate in the rest of the discussion. I'll explain my method in another post. After that, we discussed how to convert their whiteboard argument into a formal summary. We definitely reviewed the differences in scientific writing vs. English class writing - to put it bluntly, they were relieved. HW - write the summary.

So, I've started assessing the labs and the summaries - they are actually getting several different "grades" (I need to stop using that word!) for this lab. The first was an SBG assessment - SP4.2 from CB - Plan & Implement Data Collection Strategies - that was the comments on their posters and further comments in Active Grade on a 0-4 scale. This was also a group type of grade - so nothing individual just yet. Made it easy to copy/paste the comments for each group - I got to know who was in what group better, and the scoring was a little faster than what I did earlier today. I did do a "formal" lab grade for their lab revisions and data collection they actually conducted. Some were still weak and did not take the comments I made into consideration. Example: one group had no controls listed at all and several group did not indicate the different levels of their independent variables. I don't *think* they will be asked to completely redesign a lab as an FRQ as in years past on the AP exam, however, they DO need to recognize elements of good and poor lab design (oooohhhh..... I feel a good, general FRQ coming on from this lab!). Finally, I'm going through the summaries today and scoring/assessing those on the SBG 0-4 scale. I've only done one class so far, but I only had a couple of 1.5 scores where they just did not provide parts of the argument that were essential. Most grades were in the 2-2.5 range, and a couple that I couldn't quite give a 3 yet, but still had outstanding elements that I did a 2.75.

I've only done one class, but it's promising. I did enjoy being able to TYPE the comments into Active Grade! I type so much faster than I write AND they can READ the comments - most cannot read my handwriting. I still made notes in their lab notebooks re: their lab design - but the specificity of Active Grade is just fantastic. LOVE IT!

Once I figure out how to get some pictures up onto the blog from my tablet, I'll post.

All in all - a really good start to AP this week. Have not gotten to the honors SBG yet - but that will happen this weekend. So there might be another post....

No comments:

Post a Comment