Well, I don't think I'm to the "ugly" stage of change just yet - maybe in a few weeks it will be different, but I hope not.
Change is on us at school. Our standards are changing. The way we need to approach our instruction and assessment is changing. How we sequence our course needs to change.
However, not everyone I work with is seeing things in the same light. That was evident this morning.
They want to go BACK to "what we've always done" - it wasn't phrased that way, of course, but the circling around to it and the descriptions they were supplying all point to - let's go back into the box of stuff that we are comfortable with, even though it doesn't work.
It's like Dave Ramsey and debt - it's the stinky diaper mentality. "When it comes to money, we can be like the toddler in a soiled
diaper. ‘I know it smells bad, but it’s warm and it’s mine.’ Only when
the rash comes will we cry out" I think we are in the same boat - it's warm and it's mine. But, unfortunately the diaper still has shit in it - and it stinks even worse the longer it sits.
So - I'm wondering how long it will take for the smell to be so rank that people will wake up.
We are moving to 3D teaching and assessment. If you're not sure what that is, then either you've had your head in the sand for the last five years, or you're not a science teacher. It's NGSS. We're not NGSS, but we are based on the Frameworks, and so is NGSS. So similar, but our DCIs are very different.
What is most frustrating is the teachers who want to go back to the stinky diaper have really NOT had a chance to REALLY look at the new framworks, NOR do they have a full understanding of 3D teaching or 3D assessment. I've been involved with this for four years now and I'm still not 100% comfortable with designing instruction or assessment. They have had limited knowledge on it, but think they are experts. Hmmmmm....
Perfect example, one teacher who has said, repeatedly, that everything that she has done this year is already "3D" and she should just be able to "put the new standards in to everything" and then "just add the concepts in." Um, no. That's not how 3D works.
Other talk came up about spiraling - which is what the new framework is designed to help do - keep implementing the standards throughout the course, not just a "one and done" deal and move on. They insist that "Oh, this time, we will spiral it." Okay, let's see it. Give me an example. Another teacher says "We've been spiraling things all year" - I doubt it. She thinks that just mentioning a topic again in a different unit is "spiraling" - it's not. Asking students to take a new concept they are learning - say in a lab - and then relating it back to what they have learned previously and linking the two together in a new way to reinforce learning - THAT would be spiraling. Just mentioning the word or topic again - not spiraling.
So - it's going to be an uphill battle. One teacher and I agree on it - one. There are 9 of us total. However, as stated at the meeting - unless we have a full framework outlined as is already done by the state and by June 2nd, then no, we cannot completely re-sequence the course and then just "build as we go" - that is NOT going to work. Things must be done and be done in FULL.
Yeah, change can be good if you embrace it, bad if you can't handle it, and downright smelly and ugly if you completely go against it. And who will take the hit of the smelly diaper - our kids :(
An online journal to reflect on my teaching practice - what's working, what's not - and links to others that offer good suggestions and instructional practices.
Thursday, May 11, 2017
Monday, May 8, 2017
Feedback on Trial 1 - Generally a Success!
So, one of my classes has taken the summative assessment today. We do common summative assessments (which will need a VAST makeover for next year, but that's a different post) in our Biology PLC. This was a long quiz - 35 multiple choice questions. Most of the questions were DOK level 2.
Where I was able to fully implement the 5E model - the results were excellent! Now, this was the "easier" material of ecology (food webs/chains/energy/biomagnification). BUT, I'm encouraged by the results on that standard (2.91 - so in the Proficient range), and the other two were NOT in the toilet - which they usually are because it's cellular energy. The other two dealt with enzymes and energy, and then cell respiration and photosynthesis.
What was really great were some of the questions asked by my students. One in particular stood out...we did the spinach disk demo and then followed up with some discussion on that question. There was a similar (not quite the same) question on the test. It was a slightly more elaborate set up in the picture of an "underwater plant" and then it labeled some of the apparatus. It had a closed funnel over it and showed gas bubbles leaving the plant. It asked what was being released. In just one class, over 60% got that correct. And, a student even asked me to clarify if it was a similar lab to what we had done - which means the majority of them REMEMBERED that lab from over 2 weeks ago! I'll take that level of retention right now!
Now, not everyone has scored or even taken this quiz yet, but my students outscored one other teacher on all but 7 of the questions. I'll take that right now.
I still have two more classes to quiz. For the moment, it appears that changing up what I was doing and going into a bit more depth using the 5E worked - especially on the first part where I was actually able to implement the full 5E. For the cellular energy, I had to cut it short due to time :( BUT, this is encouraging and has made me excited to plan more for next year. Although, I have grading and work to finish up before I can start doing that...sigh...
Where I was able to fully implement the 5E model - the results were excellent! Now, this was the "easier" material of ecology (food webs/chains/energy/biomagnification). BUT, I'm encouraged by the results on that standard (2.91 - so in the Proficient range), and the other two were NOT in the toilet - which they usually are because it's cellular energy. The other two dealt with enzymes and energy, and then cell respiration and photosynthesis.
What was really great were some of the questions asked by my students. One in particular stood out...we did the spinach disk demo and then followed up with some discussion on that question. There was a similar (not quite the same) question on the test. It was a slightly more elaborate set up in the picture of an "underwater plant" and then it labeled some of the apparatus. It had a closed funnel over it and showed gas bubbles leaving the plant. It asked what was being released. In just one class, over 60% got that correct. And, a student even asked me to clarify if it was a similar lab to what we had done - which means the majority of them REMEMBERED that lab from over 2 weeks ago! I'll take that level of retention right now!
Now, not everyone has scored or even taken this quiz yet, but my students outscored one other teacher on all but 7 of the questions. I'll take that right now.
I still have two more classes to quiz. For the moment, it appears that changing up what I was doing and going into a bit more depth using the 5E worked - especially on the first part where I was actually able to implement the full 5E. For the cellular energy, I had to cut it short due to time :( BUT, this is encouraging and has made me excited to plan more for next year. Although, I have grading and work to finish up before I can start doing that...sigh...
Saturday, April 29, 2017
5E Model - Trial 1
Seems like I never have time to blog! However, I need to get thoughts down on something I tried and it *seems* to be working very well - which means more work to implement in ALL of my courses next year...
So, anytime I go to a conference, I come back with a BUNCH of ideas, thoughts and basically a spinning head. Unfortunately - or fortunately, it depends on how you look at it! - NSTA usually happens in late spring. So, I only have 2 months of school or so to go until summer. The unfortunate part is I don't have time to implement things immediately. The fortunate is it's almost summer where I can sit, reflect and think, and then begin to revise for next year.
Well, I went ahead and revamped my last unit based on a book that I tore through in about 2 days. I needed more time, even though it was short, just because I was making some notes and writing down ideas. I've started a OneNote Notebook for PD books that I'm tackling. I make a lot of notes IN the books, but need to have one place to collate my thoughts and ideas and to make sense of it - in other words, a place to pull it all together.
The book is 5E: Creating Teaachable Moments by Bybee. Now, I thought I WAS using the 5E model pretty well. Ummmm....yeah, not so much. There were some key elements I was missing in the implementation of the model. And they are pretty critical to the success of the model. I've been reading about 5E for a long time. This was the first time I've really had it pull together for me. Again, it's a short read, but very valuable.
Here's what I started to implement:
First, there needs to be some type of linking question to get students to connect between the different sequences of the model. They need to be aware of how they should be looking at information and a guiding / linking question is the key for this.
Second, the book also addresses (somewhat) how this works within the NGSS. Our state is NOT NGSS, but our new standards are based on the Frameworks, and the NGSS is as well. So, what really differs is the content of our standards - the structure of them is pretty similar to NGSS. So, identifyin the DCI, CCC and SEP is also important.
Third, the main step I was missing was between the Explore and Explain step! After the Explore activity, students really need to explicitly provide their explanations for what happened in the Explore, PRIOR to getting any direct Explanation of the information they have been learning. There needs to be some processing by them to work through the information.
Fourth, within each step, there does need to be a key concept to help create focus as well - and it should be a part of the CCC for the lesson / unit.
Finally, the Elaboration activity is REALLY necessary. And it doesn't need to be long, but it does need to be in place to really solidify what they have learned and give them time to apply what they have learned, as well as extend what they have learned in a different context.
So, here's how I modified the beginning of my unit (the last unit we do) to try and implement this better:
The DCI was on populations and biodiversity, the CCC was Cause & Effect, and the SEP was Analyze Data and Explanations. We also have MYP requirements, which I won't describe here.
The Engage activity was using the BioInteractive Scientist at Work Video on Ant Surveys in Gorongosa National Park. Now, I teach in a Title 1 school with students who don't have a lot of interest in school. So, I'll admit, I was REALLY nervous on using this video (and it's short) to a group of 10th graders who don't really care much about Biology - for them, it's a hoop to jump through for graduation. I was surprised! In all 3 classes, the majority of them were engaged in the video, asking questions during the video and NOT sleeping! I even had two students turn their desks so they faced front to the screen so they could see better! Okay, not what I was expecting, so that made me a bit more confident in my plans.
The next part was pure luck - I actually FOUND a graph that was a scatter plot with a trend line on Ant Diversity! So, we did that in their BILL next using the I2 strategy from BSCS - the inventors of the 5E :) They still stayed engaged and with the lesson - contributing based on what they saw in the graph, as well as information they had from the video. We also went through a list on the board prior to that based on the question "Why are ants so important to us? Why would anyone care about ants or care about studying ants?" I had them give me some information from the video and left that up for the remainder of class so they could refer back to it.
For the Explore activity, I posted the linking question on their activity - "How can biodiversity be determined in an ecosystem?" Now, reflecting back, I know I need to adjust this from "how" to "why is biodiversity important to an ecosystem?" They did an activity to determine Biodiversity from a bag of random objects and did some quick math of # of different species / # of total species. The closer to 1 the decimal, the more diverse the environment. I modified it from the activity found here.
Both of those took about 1 class period - and I'm on block schedule. This was the opening of the unit, so we also had some setup to do for BILL for the unit divider and learning map.
For the Explain, I did have them do some explanation from the Explore activity first, but next time I need to be more explicit in HOW they are doing this so they see the importance. I think perhaps an opening question where they give me a description of what they think biodiversity is and why it's important. They did a CER at the end of the Explore activity, but I don't think that is enough. However, they did do some Plicker questions (fantastic resource if you've not used it yet!). For the Explanation, I did some direct instruction with the linking question between the two: "How can populations be affected by other factors besides location?" This then moved us into Keystone species and interactions between organisms and how this can impact both biodiversity and the food web. Food webs and food chains were on the horizon! The Keystone Species activity is one I've created and it uses the BioInteractive Some Animals are More Equal than Others Short Film. I use this at the end of the activity. They do some graphing to see the impact.
The last part is the Elaborate. To link, the question was: "What different types of populations are there and how are they impacted by change?" The activity here was Oh, Deer! which can be found on a variety of websites. Again, this is a QUICK activity for elaborate, with the goal / key concept of+ limiting factors in a population. So, it moves from interactions between organisms to interactions between organisms and their environment.
We do common summative assessments at my school. Due to the timing with unit 4, we decided to do a short quiz (20 questions + a short response based on data), then a test for the middle of the unit with only MC questions, and then a final short quiz similar to the first one. We use an online system that can generate a LOT of data. Comparing mine to others in the department:
Proficient + Developing category (which is how we are judged on our state End of Course test):
Me: 90.4%
All other classes: 86.4%
I had fewer students in the Beginning category as well.
On the short response, I did not score anything lower than 8 out of 10. The responses I got, even from my STRUGGLING learners, was MUCH higher in structure and knowledge than I've gotten from them all year! When added into their MC grades, this caused most of them to at least pass with a C or D, instead of outright failing.
Now, I also had a student teacher with me this semester - she is still developing and even when I'm modeling the lesson, she still sometimes forgets things, so I'm taking that into consideration. I think they should have had higher scores, but some information was "glossed over" as she didn't really have a vision of where I was headed with these strategies. Yes, I should go over these things with her. However, she is late pretty much every day (and has been spoken to many times about this) so it does not leave time to go over things prior to teaching most days.
With all that, I know changes need to be made and things always need to be tweaked. However, I'm initially pretty excited by how this played out. This was maybe 3 days of instruction (so like 6 on a regular schedule) and I see students every OTHER day. I was happy with the level of retention - which seemed much better even in my lower class.
I'm currently doing this with my next part of the unit. However, due to time, it will not be implemented fully. However, even partial implementation that is correct is better than full implementation that was incorrect. It's also better than what most teachers at my school are doing - which is "sit and get" and skimming over information with straight lecture and worksheet - which research says (repeatedly) does not work for long term understanding or retention, or even for short term understanding.
I'm working my way through other books - so hoping more ideas will be forthcoming.
So, anytime I go to a conference, I come back with a BUNCH of ideas, thoughts and basically a spinning head. Unfortunately - or fortunately, it depends on how you look at it! - NSTA usually happens in late spring. So, I only have 2 months of school or so to go until summer. The unfortunate part is I don't have time to implement things immediately. The fortunate is it's almost summer where I can sit, reflect and think, and then begin to revise for next year.
Well, I went ahead and revamped my last unit based on a book that I tore through in about 2 days. I needed more time, even though it was short, just because I was making some notes and writing down ideas. I've started a OneNote Notebook for PD books that I'm tackling. I make a lot of notes IN the books, but need to have one place to collate my thoughts and ideas and to make sense of it - in other words, a place to pull it all together.
The book is 5E: Creating Teaachable Moments by Bybee. Now, I thought I WAS using the 5E model pretty well. Ummmm....yeah, not so much. There were some key elements I was missing in the implementation of the model. And they are pretty critical to the success of the model. I've been reading about 5E for a long time. This was the first time I've really had it pull together for me. Again, it's a short read, but very valuable.
Here's what I started to implement:
First, there needs to be some type of linking question to get students to connect between the different sequences of the model. They need to be aware of how they should be looking at information and a guiding / linking question is the key for this.
Second, the book also addresses (somewhat) how this works within the NGSS. Our state is NOT NGSS, but our new standards are based on the Frameworks, and the NGSS is as well. So, what really differs is the content of our standards - the structure of them is pretty similar to NGSS. So, identifyin the DCI, CCC and SEP is also important.
Third, the main step I was missing was between the Explore and Explain step! After the Explore activity, students really need to explicitly provide their explanations for what happened in the Explore, PRIOR to getting any direct Explanation of the information they have been learning. There needs to be some processing by them to work through the information.
Fourth, within each step, there does need to be a key concept to help create focus as well - and it should be a part of the CCC for the lesson / unit.
Finally, the Elaboration activity is REALLY necessary. And it doesn't need to be long, but it does need to be in place to really solidify what they have learned and give them time to apply what they have learned, as well as extend what they have learned in a different context.
So, here's how I modified the beginning of my unit (the last unit we do) to try and implement this better:
The DCI was on populations and biodiversity, the CCC was Cause & Effect, and the SEP was Analyze Data and Explanations. We also have MYP requirements, which I won't describe here.
The Engage activity was using the BioInteractive Scientist at Work Video on Ant Surveys in Gorongosa National Park. Now, I teach in a Title 1 school with students who don't have a lot of interest in school. So, I'll admit, I was REALLY nervous on using this video (and it's short) to a group of 10th graders who don't really care much about Biology - for them, it's a hoop to jump through for graduation. I was surprised! In all 3 classes, the majority of them were engaged in the video, asking questions during the video and NOT sleeping! I even had two students turn their desks so they faced front to the screen so they could see better! Okay, not what I was expecting, so that made me a bit more confident in my plans.
The next part was pure luck - I actually FOUND a graph that was a scatter plot with a trend line on Ant Diversity! So, we did that in their BILL next using the I2 strategy from BSCS - the inventors of the 5E :) They still stayed engaged and with the lesson - contributing based on what they saw in the graph, as well as information they had from the video. We also went through a list on the board prior to that based on the question "Why are ants so important to us? Why would anyone care about ants or care about studying ants?" I had them give me some information from the video and left that up for the remainder of class so they could refer back to it.
For the Explore activity, I posted the linking question on their activity - "How can biodiversity be determined in an ecosystem?" Now, reflecting back, I know I need to adjust this from "how" to "why is biodiversity important to an ecosystem?" They did an activity to determine Biodiversity from a bag of random objects and did some quick math of # of different species / # of total species. The closer to 1 the decimal, the more diverse the environment. I modified it from the activity found here.
Both of those took about 1 class period - and I'm on block schedule. This was the opening of the unit, so we also had some setup to do for BILL for the unit divider and learning map.
For the Explain, I did have them do some explanation from the Explore activity first, but next time I need to be more explicit in HOW they are doing this so they see the importance. I think perhaps an opening question where they give me a description of what they think biodiversity is and why it's important. They did a CER at the end of the Explore activity, but I don't think that is enough. However, they did do some Plicker questions (fantastic resource if you've not used it yet!). For the Explanation, I did some direct instruction with the linking question between the two: "How can populations be affected by other factors besides location?" This then moved us into Keystone species and interactions between organisms and how this can impact both biodiversity and the food web. Food webs and food chains were on the horizon! The Keystone Species activity is one I've created and it uses the BioInteractive Some Animals are More Equal than Others Short Film. I use this at the end of the activity. They do some graphing to see the impact.
The last part is the Elaborate. To link, the question was: "What different types of populations are there and how are they impacted by change?" The activity here was Oh, Deer! which can be found on a variety of websites. Again, this is a QUICK activity for elaborate, with the goal / key concept of+ limiting factors in a population. So, it moves from interactions between organisms to interactions between organisms and their environment.
We do common summative assessments at my school. Due to the timing with unit 4, we decided to do a short quiz (20 questions + a short response based on data), then a test for the middle of the unit with only MC questions, and then a final short quiz similar to the first one. We use an online system that can generate a LOT of data. Comparing mine to others in the department:
Proficient + Developing category (which is how we are judged on our state End of Course test):
Me: 90.4%
All other classes: 86.4%
I had fewer students in the Beginning category as well.
On the short response, I did not score anything lower than 8 out of 10. The responses I got, even from my STRUGGLING learners, was MUCH higher in structure and knowledge than I've gotten from them all year! When added into their MC grades, this caused most of them to at least pass with a C or D, instead of outright failing.
Now, I also had a student teacher with me this semester - she is still developing and even when I'm modeling the lesson, she still sometimes forgets things, so I'm taking that into consideration. I think they should have had higher scores, but some information was "glossed over" as she didn't really have a vision of where I was headed with these strategies. Yes, I should go over these things with her. However, she is late pretty much every day (and has been spoken to many times about this) so it does not leave time to go over things prior to teaching most days.
With all that, I know changes need to be made and things always need to be tweaked. However, I'm initially pretty excited by how this played out. This was maybe 3 days of instruction (so like 6 on a regular schedule) and I see students every OTHER day. I was happy with the level of retention - which seemed much better even in my lower class.
I'm currently doing this with my next part of the unit. However, due to time, it will not be implemented fully. However, even partial implementation that is correct is better than full implementation that was incorrect. It's also better than what most teachers at my school are doing - which is "sit and get" and skimming over information with straight lecture and worksheet - which research says (repeatedly) does not work for long term understanding or retention, or even for short term understanding.
I'm working my way through other books - so hoping more ideas will be forthcoming.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)